The payroll software 400,000+ small businesses use. $40/month Simple plan, unlimited payroll runs, automatic tax filing. The clear pick for SMB payroll — with real limits at scale.
Gusto is the right answer for most small businesses needing payroll. The Simple plan at $40/month + $6/employee handles full-service payroll, automatic federal/state/local tax filing, unlimited payroll runs, and basic benefits administration. Most users finish payroll in under 5 minutes. The interface is genuinely easy — non-accountants can run it. The catch: Simple lacks multi-state tax filing, time tracking, and HR tools (those live on Plus at $80 + $12/employee). For 1099-only businesses, the Contractor Only plan at $35 + $6/contractor is the right fit. Customer support quality is the recurring weak point, especially compared to Paychex.
Gusto is our first payroll review on VerdictScout — opening up the broader 'SMB operations' category beyond marketing tools. If you're running a service business or growing past your first hire, payroll is one of the few tools where picking right early genuinely matters. Switching providers mid-year costs days of cleanup work.
Most SMB owners describe their relationship with payroll as 'the thing I dread doing every two weeks.' Gusto's primary contribution is making it not feel that way.
The interface walks you through onboarding step-by-step. Federal, state, and local taxes file automatically. Employees self-serve their own info, paystubs, and benefits through Gusto Wallet. New hire reporting goes to the state without you touching it. AutoPilot can run recurring payroll without input on the standard schedule.
For most small businesses with 1-20 employees in a single state, Gusto Simple ($40 base + $6/employee) is genuinely sufficient. A 5-person team pays $70/month all-in. A 10-person team pays $100/month. That's competitive with QuickBooks Payroll and Square Payroll while including better HR features.
The plan upgrade decision is feature-driven, not price-driven:
Simple → Plus ($40 → $80 base, $6 → $12/ee): Upgrade when you need any of (a) multi-state payroll filing, (b) integrated time tracking, (c) advanced PTO management, or (d) performance review tools. Most growing SMBs hit the multi-state trigger first as they hire remote employees.
Plus → Premium (custom pricing): Upgrade when you need a dedicated point of contact at Gusto, proactive compliance guidance, or HR advisor access. For most teams under 50 employees, Plus is sufficient. Premium makes sense in regulated industries (healthcare, finance) or when payroll complexity hits the wall.
Contractor Only ($35 + $6/c): If you have zero W-2 employees and only pay 1099 contractors, this plan exists specifically for you. Global contractor payments have no monthly per-contractor fee — only a small service and FX fee per payment.
vs QuickBooks Payroll: QuickBooks is cheaper at the entry tier ($45/mo + $6/ee for Core) but has weaker HR features, no built-in time tracking on lower plans, and a more dated interface. Gusto's Simple wins on user experience and HR depth at similar price. QuickBooks wins only if you're already deeply embedded in the QuickBooks accounting ecosystem.
vs Paychex: Paychex is the legacy enterprise-friendly alternative — better for businesses over 100 employees, businesses needing 24/7 phone support, and complex multi-state operations. Paychex pricing is opaque (quote-based) and typically more expensive at SMB scale. Most SMBs under 50 employees should pick Gusto.
vs Rippling: Rippling is more capable at integrating IT, HR, and payroll into a unified platform — but starts more expensive ($35+/employee on Rippling Unity vs $6 on Gusto Simple) and is overkill for businesses that just need payroll. Pick Rippling only if you're scaling past 50 employees and need IT provisioning bundled with payroll.
Customer support is the recurring complaint. Gusto support is email-first with limited phone hours. Both Trustpilot and BBB show consistent reviews about slow response times. For a tool you depend on for time-sensitive tax filings, this is a real weakness. Paychex offers 24/7 phone support — Gusto doesn't.
HR features are basic, not full HRIS. Performance reviews, document management, and advanced HR analytics work for businesses under 50 employees but feel limiting for companies hitting 100+. At that scale, dedicated HRIS platforms like BambooHR or Rippling become more capable.
No same-day direct deposit. Next-day direct deposit is available on Plus and Premium; Simple plan limits to 2-day standard timing. For employees who expect modern instant pay, this is a meaningful gap. Square Payroll offers same-day, Gusto doesn't.
No free plan or extended trial. Gusto requires payment from day one — no free tier, no extended trial. You can cancel anytime, but the upfront commitment is a friction point versus competitors offering 30-60 day trials.
Limited screen customization. Unlike Paychex or ADP, you can't rearrange dashboard widgets or customize the interface for power users. For most SMBs this is fine; for HR specialists running heavy reporting workflows, it's frustrating.
SaaS prices change constantly. We check 25+ pricing pages every quarter and send one email with everything that changed.
✓ You're in — we'll send one email per quarter.
Yes for any business with W-2 employees. The combined cost of payroll + tax filing + basic HR + benefits administration would run $80-120/month if you bought separately. For 1-10 employee businesses, Gusto Simple is consistently the highest-value option in the category.
Yes — federal, state, and local payroll taxes file automatically on every plan, including Simple. W-2s and 1099s generate at year-end automatically. Year-end forms are included in the base plan; you don't pay extra at tax season.
Gusto for better user experience and stronger HR features at similar price. QuickBooks Payroll if you're already running QuickBooks Online for accounting and want everything in one ecosystem. Gusto integrates with QuickBooks Online too — most accountants recommend Gusto for payroll specifically and let it sync to QuickBooks for accounting.
Yes — the Contractor Only plan ($35/month + $6/contractor) is purpose-built for businesses with no W-2 employees. Global contractor payments have no monthly per-contractor fee. If you ever bring on W-2 employees, you'll need to upgrade to Simple or higher.
Only on the Plus plan ($80 + $12/ee) and above. Simple plan files for one state only. If you have remote employees in multiple states, you'll need Plus or pay separately for each state's filing — which is why most growing remote teams skip Simple and start on Plus.
Most businesses complete onboarding in 1-3 hours for new payroll setups. Migration from another payroll provider can take 1-2 weeks if mid-year (gathering YTD payroll data, prior tax filings, etc). Premium plan includes full migration assistance.
The payroll software 400,000+ small businesses use. $40/month Simple plan, unlimited payroll runs, automatic tax filing. The clear pick for SMB payroll — with real limits at scale.